From Favorites to Outcasts: How Narcissistic Fathers Impact the Relationship Dynamics between Their Daughters, Creating a Preferred Child and a Black Sheep

From Favorites to Outcasts: How Narcissistic Fathers Impact the Relationship Dynamics between Their Daughters, Creating a Preferred Child and a Black Sheep

Image Source: Unsplash


Disclosure - this article may contain affiliate links for which I may receive compensation for their use. See full disclosure/disclaimer here: Disclaimer/Disclosure – Stylin Spirit (

In the complex and delicate realm of family dynamics, the impact of a narcissistic father on his daughters can be profound and lasting. From shaping their self-esteem to influencing their relationship dynamics, these fathers often create a preferred child and a black sheep within the family unit. This article delves into the intricate layers of this phenomenon, shedding light on the emotional and psychological effects experienced by the daughters.


Understanding the Impact on Daughters

Growing up with a narcissistic father can have significant consequences for daughters. The favored child, often referred to as the "golden child," is typically showered with attention, love, and praise. The narcissistic father chooses this child as a reflection of his grandiosity and superiority. The golden child is treated as special, with their achievements exaggerated and their flaws overlooked. This preferential treatment can lead to feelings of entitlement, arrogance, and an inflated sense of self-worth.

On the other hand, the black sheep, or scapegoat, is the daughter who is often overlooked, invalidated, or even undermined by the narcissistic father. This child may be subjected to constant criticism, blame, or emotional neglect. The black sheep are usually seen as family problems or troublemakers, regardless of their behavior. They are often made to feel unwanted, unloved, and unworthy, leading to deep-seated feelings of inadequacy, self-doubt, and even self-hatred.

Characteristics of a Preferred Child

The preferred child, as chosen by the narcissistic father, typically exhibits certain characteristics. They tend to be the daughter who mirrors the father's traits, interests, and beliefs. This child may be praised excessively for their achievements, no matter how small, and may receive special privileges or preferential treatment within the family. They are often shielded from criticism or consequences, leading to a sense of entitlement and a lack of accountability for their actions. The preferred child may also internalize the narcissistic parent's behavior and adopt similar narcissistic traits themselves.

It is important to note that being the preferred child is not without its own set of challenges. While they may receive praise and admiration from the narcissistic father, this often comes at the cost of their authenticity and independence. The pressure to constantly meet the father's expectations can lead to a lack of personal identity and a fear of disappointing others. The preferred child may struggle with forming genuine relationships and may experience difficulties in their personal and professional lives.

Characteristics of a Black Sheep

The black sheep, on the other hand, often bears the brunt of the narcissistic father's emotional abuse. This daughter is typically scapegoated and blamed for family problems or conflicts, regardless of their involvement. The black sheep may be constantly criticized, belittled, or ignored by the narcissistic father, leading to feelings of isolation, shame, and worthlessness. They may develop a strong sense of empathy and compassion for others, as they have experienced firsthand the pain and suffering caused by the narcissistic father's behavior.

The black sheep may also exhibit rebellious or oppositional behavior as a response to the constant invalidation and mistreatment. This can be a coping mechanism to assert their individuality and protect themselves from further emotional harm. However, this behavior can also lead to strained relationships with other family members, as the black sheep may struggle to trust and form close connections due to their past experiences.

The Role of the Narcissistic Father in Creating the Preferred Child

The narcissistic father plays a crucial role in creating the preferred child within the family dynamic. Their need for admiration and validation leads them to choose a daughter who reflects their desired image. The father may see the golden child as an extension of themselves, someone who can fulfill their unmet needs and provide a source of narcissistic supply. This dynamic allows the narcissistic father to bask in the reflected glory of the preferred child's achievements, reinforcing their own sense of superiority and importance.

The preferred child is often groomed to fulfill the narcissistic father's expectations and desires. They may be encouraged to pursue certain activities, careers, or relationships that align with the father's interests and values. The golden child becomes a source of narcissistic supply for the father, providing constant validation and admiration. This creates a co-dependent relationship where the preferred child's self-worth is tied to their ability to meet the father's expectations and fulfill his emotional needs.

The Role of the Narcissistic Father in Creating the Black Sheep

While the narcissistic father may lavish attention and praise on the preferred child, they often neglect and mistreat the black sheep. The black sheep becomes the scapegoat for the father's frustrations, insecurities, and shortcomings. They are blamed for any problems or conflicts within the family, regardless of their involvement. The narcissistic father may project their flaws onto the black sheep, using them as a target for their feelings of inadequacy or shame.

The black sheep is often subjected to constant criticism, emotional neglect, or even outright rejection. The narcissistic father may undermine their achievements, dismiss their feelings, or invalidate their experiences. This consistent invalidation leads the black sheep to internalize the belief that they are inherently flawed or unworthy of love and acceptance. The father's mistreatment creates a toxic and hostile environment for the black sheep, further reinforcing their role as the family outcast.

Emotional and Psychological Effects on the Preferred Child

While the preferred child may receive praise and admiration from the narcissistic father, this dynamic comes at a cost. The constant pressure to meet the father's expectations and maintain their image of perfection can lead to significant emotional and psychological effects. The preferred child may struggle with a distorted sense of self-worth, basing their value solely on external validation and achievements. They may develop a fear of failure or disappointment, as they have learned that their worth is contingent on meeting the father's standards.

Additionally, the preferred child may struggle to form genuine relationships outside the family. They may have difficulty trusting others and rely on manipulating or controlling behaviors to maintain their superiority and control. The constant need for admiration and validation can also lead to emptiness and dissatisfaction, as the preferred child never feels genuinely seen or loved for who they are.

Emotional and Psychological Effects on the Black Sheep

The emotional and psychological effects on the black sheep of a narcissistic father can be devastating. Constant criticism, blame, and emotional neglect can lead to a deep sense of shame, self-doubt, and worthlessness. The black sheep may struggle with their self-esteem and may develop a negative self-image as a result of the father's mistreatment. They may internalize the belief that they are inherently flawed or unlovable, leading to difficulty forming healthy relationships and trusting others.

The black sheep may also experience feelings of isolation and loneliness, as they are often ostracized or excluded within the family unit. Their role as the family problem or troublemaker can lead to a sense of alienation and a lack of support from other family members. The constant invalidation and mistreatment can result in anxiety, depression, or other mental health issues for the black sheep as they struggle to navigate the complex aftermath of growing up with a narcissistic father.

Coping Strategies for Daughters of Narcissistic Fathers

Navigating the aftermath of growing up with a narcissistic father can be challenging, but there are coping strategies that can help daughters heal and reclaim their lives. Seeking therapy or counseling is often a crucial step in the healing process, as it provides a safe space to explore and process the emotional wounds inflicted by the narcissistic father. Therapy can help daughters develop healthy coping mechanisms, rebuild their self-esteem, and establish boundaries with toxic family members.

Building a support network is also vital for daughters of narcissistic fathers. Surrounding oneself with trusted friends, mentors, or support groups can provide validation, understanding, and encouragement. Sharing experiences with others who have gone through similar situations can be empowering and help daughters feel less alone in their journey.

Practicing self-care and self-compassion is another essential aspect of healing. Daughters must prioritize their well-being, set healthy boundaries, and engage in activities that bring them joy and fulfillment. Learning to love and accept oneself, despite the messages of unworthiness instilled by the narcissistic father, is a powerful and transformative process.

Conclusion and Resources for Further Support

Growing up with a narcissistic father can have profound and lasting effects on daughters. Creating a preferred child and a black sheep within the family unit can result in strained sibling relationships, deep-seated feelings of inadequacy, and a distorted sense of self-worth. Understanding the impact of these dynamics is a crucial step towards healing and breaking the cycle.

If you or someone you know is struggling with the aftermath of growing up with a narcissistic father, seeking professional help is strongly encouraged. Therapists, counselors, and support groups specializing in narcissistic abuse can provide guidance, validation, and support on the journey toward healing and reclaiming one's life.

Remember, you are not alone, and there is hope for healing and finding a sense of self-worth beyond the shadows of a narcissistic father.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Picture of Danielle and her son

Remember in life, everything is a practice, not a perfect. Doing your best is all you can do and that is enough!

Please help me create a supportive space here, comment and share!

Featured collection Handcrafted Items

Welcome! I am Danielle the owner at Stylin' Spirit. I am a woman, mother, survivor, designer and I would love to share my creative works with you.

1 of 4